Friday, September 16, 2016

Revenge of the Nostalgic versus the Apathy of Youth

Donald Trump is now somewhat shockingly within range of winning this race.  There are still certainly hurdles in the way of his victory. But we must admit that he is now closer than we expected him to get, and it can be relatively easily asserted that the race is virtually tied.  What is causing this? The answer is quite simply one of generation.   Donald Trump is the candidate of the old.  There is a profound hunger and nostalgia among many in America for the way things used to be.  Donald Trump’s entire being in this campaign has spoken to that.   Worried about the complications of the world from Trade, to Immigration, to Technological change or threats like ISIS?  All of these things, Trump tells us, can be overcome by American strength. Those who tell you otherwise are weak and stupid.  That is the core of the Trump message from the beginning of his campaign, and it has never wavered. It is a view embraced by 40% of Americans and if you go to the RCP average even as the race spirals into a tie, the four-way average still puts Trump at 40.9% of the vote.   The two way average adds 3.1% to get Trump to 44% as Republicans return to the flock.    Older voters and less educated voters lead the pack for Trump. Whites without a college degree give Trump 58% of their votes and almost certainly over 60% if you include voters old enough to be unlikely to have had a chance at college.  This base of voters is fired up and energized, and their candidate from the primary was victorious.                 

On the other side, many voters under the age of 30 had to taste political defeat for the first time during the primaries. (Obviously they have also lost in midterms, but they also barely voted in the midterms). These voters are still grappling with the loss.  Voters under 30 overwhelmingly do not like Donald Trump, are not voting for Donald Trump and think he is not qualified to be President. However they also have bought into many of the negative Hillary Clinton memes and thus are making up a smaller % of the electorate and voting for Clinton at considerably less of a rate than those whites without a college degree are voting for Trump.  The forces of nostalgia want to win badly and the future of the country thinks everything is terrible so why bother.  There is still time for this to change, and debates do have an effect of crystalizing opinion. But for the moment the power of Nostalgia seems to be keeping Trump in serious contention. These voters badly want this, and that can sometimes be enough. 

Share:

0 comments:

Post a Comment

The Scorecard

The Scorecard

The Scorecard is a political strategy and analysis blog. Our hope is to provide information and insight that can be found nowhere else into how and why things are happening in American politics. Unlike many political pundits, we will tell you who we think is going to win as an election approaches; we will tell you why; and we will give you a sense of our level of confidence. Ours is a holistic approach, one that takes in as many numbers as possible but is also willing to look past the numbers if need be. When we turn out to have been wrong, we will let you know. When we are right, we’ll let you know that too.

Our Delegate Math


Delegate Count


Delegate Contests

About Me

Delegate Count

Author Jason Paul is a longtime political operative who got his start as an intern in 2002. He has been a political forecaster for almost as long. He won the 2006 Swing State Project election prediction contest and has won two other local contests. He had the pulse of Obama-Clinton race in 2008 and has been as good as anyone at delegate math in the 2016 race. He looks forwards to providing quality coverage for the remainder of the 2016 race.